
It’s no secret: When high schools don’t offer calculus, students are less likely to take it. Thanks to the federal Civil Rights Data Collection (CRDC)—a biennial survey administered by the U.S. Department of Education since 1968—we know that there have long been disparities in access to the course.
But, two years into the current presidential administration, history has begun to disappear before our very eyes.
Just Equations has tracked high school calculus coursetaking for years. We argue strongly that high schools should offer other rigorous math courses in addition to calculus. Nevertheless, calculus coursetaking is an important metric for several reasons: Some high schools offer no other options, and calculus is an important stepping stone for students pursuing STEM majors. Plus, though calculus should not be weighted in admissions outside of those majors, it frequently is.
These factors make equitable calculus coursetaking a priority—one that has yet to be realized, based on existing data. According to the CRDC, in 2011–12, 81 percent of Asian and 71 percent of white students attended a school with a full complement of math and science courses, including calculus. Only 67 percent of Latinx students and 57 percent of Black students attended such a school.
Four years later, when half of U.S. high schools offered calculus, only 35 percent of schools enrolling a high proportion (75 percent or more) of Black and Latinx students did so. This problem persisted through at least 2021–22, when those numbers had barely budged: 35 percent of high schools with high Black/Latinx enrollments offered the course vs. 54 percent of schools with low Black/Latinx enrollments.
Fast-forward to currently available data. Given increased attention to the issue, has calculus become more available? Or less? It is hard to say. The latest CRDC report was released in September, almost a year late. It indicates that more boys than girls take high school calculus but is completely silent on racial patterns in calculus enrollment. This is a clear result of the Trump administration rejecting diversity, equity, and inclusion goals, a stance that completely ignores the institutional barriers and systemic bias that produced the disparities in the first place.
Fortunately, other research sheds some light. From high school data collected by NAEP, we know that calculus coursetaking declined from 18 percent to 16 percent of high school graduates between 2009 and 2019, even as precalculus coursetaking increased. And in California, between 2014–15 and 2023–24, both precalculus and calculus enrollments dropped, according to research published by Policy Analysis for California Education (PACE). Enrollment in these courses—as well as in AP Statistics—is far lower for the state’s Black, Latinx, Pacific Islander, and low-income students, and lower-income students’ enrollment is declining more than other students.
These downward trends in coursetaking began before the pandemic and may contribute to declining scores on state math assessments, according to authors Kramer A. Dykeman and colleagues. In a separate study, PACE reports that nearly 10 percent of schools stopped offering calculus during the same ten-year period—another sign that the drop in calculus coursetaking is not evenly distributed. (Some of those schools simultaneously added the option for students to take calculus at a community college via dual enrollment.)
This California picture is helpful in addressing current policy debates, such as whether the University of California’s test-free admissions policy caused the system to admit less-prepared students. It seems likely that shifts in students’ coursetaking—along with other causes such as math teacher shortages and reliance on substitute teachers—played a greater role in the drops in students’ math preparation.
Other states may have similar patterns—though we know from a recent Just Equations report, Calculated Barriers, that some states do not even report data on calculus coursetaking.
Even so, state-level data are no substitute for a complete federal picture of how students are faring across the country in their educational journeys. (Another thing missing from the latest CRDC report: information on nonbinary students. Though this year’s release was supposed to be the first to include nonbinary students, those data were eliminated based on an executive order that recognizes only two sexes.)
Absent a fuller picture, our best guess is that states will need to continue to expand access to advanced math courses, which means both calculus and other rigorous courses, such as statistics, data science, and discrete math. And that efforts to redesign high school math to incorporate more modeling and data analysis into the curriculum for all students are more important than ever.
Speaking of data analysis, searching raw CRDC data files can reveal more information about demographic patterns of calculus enrollment than the Department of Education is including in its reports. It will be up to future leadership to restore education data and reporting in ways that make progress on equitable outcomes more accessible and transparent.